Monday at home, a halftime tie was broken and Holy Redeemer pulled away with the late 5-3 win.
Shane Macko and Braiden Jerome scored for Tunkhannock in a match where both teams had an own goal.
Max Shelhamer and Logan Barbini teamed up in net to stop a combined 18 savers against the Royals.
The Tigers were shut out on Thursday on the road, behind two goals from Lake-Lehman’s Max Paczewski.
Lake-Lehman goalkeeper Matt Ash blocked all nine shots he faced in a shutout performance. Tunkhannock’s Logan Barbini made 11 saves in the effort.
Tunkhannock has a game to make up, a contest against Hanover Area from Oct. 9 that will be played Thursday and added a home game against Elk Lake last night.
Playoffs for Class 3A begin on Sat. Oct. 31.
HR 5, Tunkhannock 3
First half: Own goal (HR), 14:00; Own goal (T), 28:00; Mark Atherton (HR) from Alex Rymar, 29:00; Shane Macko (T) from Tyler Berkhimer, 31:00.
Second half: John Kuderka (HR) unassisted, 41:00; Kuderka (HR) from Nicholas Smith, 48:00; Jake Ohrin (HR) from Nick Dunleavy, 49:00; Braiden Jerome (T) from Tyler Pietrowski, 60:00.
Shots-corners: HR 26-5, Tunk 19-5.
Saves: Lance McGrane (HR) 15, Max Shelhamer (T) and Logan Barbini (T) 18.
LL 2, Tunkhannock 0
First half: Max Paczewski (L-L) from Evan Kaiser, 6:43; Paczewski (L-L) from Cole Kaiser, 20:27.
Shots-corners: L-L 15-4, Tunk 9-7.
Saves: Matt Ash (L-L) 9, Logan Barbini (T) 11.